My 5 Key Takeaways From SPH FY2020’s Earnings
by Chris Lee Susanto
14 October 2020
1. Long-Term Challenge With Media Division
The first thing that comes to mind when we hear SPH is the newspaper right.
SPH owns The Strait Times, Business Times, and many other media properties.
And media normally makes money through ads.
SPH media division revenue is now less than half of what it used to be in FY 2014.
It dropped from S$963.4 million to S$445.2 million in FY 2020.
“All our major business segments were severely disrupted by Covid-19. Our Media business is badly affected by the collapse in advertising,” says CEO Ng Yat Chung.
This is expected.
The newspaper business model has been attacked and disrupted for many years now.
The newspaper business is impacted by alternatives on both the reader side as well as from the client’s side.
With the internet, it is easier for readers to get news without sticking to one particular publication.
The clients paying for newspaper ads now have better alternatives with Facebook ad, which is cheaper and more targeted.
2. Digital Revenue is Growing
Digitalization is no longer a choice, it is a necessity.
SPH’s digital revenue grew by 11.8% year on year. In FY 2020, it is S$118.3 million.
Although pretty decent, I do not think that the growth is good enough to justify any of its other division’s decline.
At least not yet.
3. Dividend Plunged From 12 cents to 2.5 cents
I think that plenty of SPH investors invest in SPH for their dividends.
But those that invested in SPH for their dividends will be disappointed with dividends plunging from 12 cents last year to 2.5 cents this year.
I have shared before in my webinar that if a company does not have a business model that supports sustainable and growing earnings, the dividends will likely not be sustainable.
And it is a dilemma for SPH too because they will need to retain more of their earnings if they want to invest for future growth.
And if they retain more earnings, they will have even less to give out as dividends in the future.
4. SPH Property Business, A Bright Spark?
I am not sure why I have been seeing companies to also a property division when their core business is not doing so well.
Think Keppel Corporation and SPH.
SPH property business revenue in FY 2020 is S$327.2 million.
It is a pretty decent size out of the total S$865.7 million of revenue they have in FY 2020.
Their property business revenue grew 10.3% year on year as compared to FY 2019 – in comparison, the media division revenue dropped 22.8% year on year.
But I am not sure that the property business will be able to allow SPH to be a growth company or even recover the revenue lost in the media segment of the business.
5. Sadly, It Will Likely Get Worst
It is noted that the group still makes an operating profit of S$110.2 million in FY 2020 even considering the Covid-19 situation.
However, their revenue has been declining for a couple of years due to the structural tailwind that they are facing especially in their media division.
Their total debt has also increased to S$3.41 billion as of 30 August 2020. Their net debt position now is at around S$2.54 billion.
One thing that is for sure is that I think their media ad earnings will continue to decline further with more businesses migrating their ad spend from traditional to digital.
And time is running out if their debt continues to increase.
Read also now: Here Are My Five Key Takeaway From Tesla 2020 Battery Day
I think that SPH is an interesting company with some interesting assets like the Straits Times, The BT, and many others.
But obviously what they have been doing is not working so far as explained by the decline in revenue from 2014 to 2020.
And it could be hard for them to succeed moving forward without radically transforming the whole business.
And my view is that in due time, their dividend will likely be cut totally if earnings continue to decline.
All in all, it’s a bad year for SPH and it will likely stay bad in the short and long-term due to the lack of differentiation in their business model.
Unless they start to do something about it.
Read also now: My 5 Key Takeaway From Temasek Portfolio Value in 2020
Was this article useful for you?
If it is, appreciate it if you could take one minute to share the above article on Facebook by clicking here.
The information provided is for educational and general information purposes only and is not intended to be personalized investment or financial advice. We make no promises as to the accuracy or usefulness of the information we present.
Important: Please read our full disclaimer.
Chris Lee Susanto
Founder of the value investing blog Re-ThinkWealth.com (if you type “value investing blog” in Google, his blog is likely the first one). Being a full-time investor himself, Chris knows that he did not beat the S&P 500 return so far (as of the time of this writing) by listening to stock tips. So, when he teaches, he also doesn’t believe in giving stock tips as it is not sustainable for you in the long run. He will teach you how to make your own intelligent decisions with his 4M1S framework. Feel free to also join his free investment telegram channel here.
More from Chris
1. Temasek Portfolio is Huge. Although I know that Temasek has a huge portfolio, I was surprised to see that it is around the size of Warren Buffett’s. As of 31 March 2020, the net portfolio value or NPV is at S$306 billion. So we have our own Warren Buffett in Singapore, that is […]
Who is Adam Smith? Adam Smith (1723-1790) was a philosopher and economist who was best known for authoring the book An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. Wealth of Nations also happens to be one of Warren Buffett’s favourite books […]
As a value investor, as a practitioner of value investing, I am very interested in studying funds I view as an executioner of the various value investing methodologies I myself am very passionate about. In this article, I will list down some of the value investing funds in […]
Being a successful investor requires us to have equanimity in everything we do. There are many benefits to keeping a gratitude journal, firstly, the balance of emotion. Would you rather make $100,000 a year but all your friends and neighbors make $200,000 a year or […]
How do people get rich by investing in stocks? Can we actually get rich by investing in stocks? Yes, we can. But we need to utilize both Patience and Compound Interest in Great Companies. With the proper foundation, framework, character, and skills, I truly believe that […]
Sun Tzu Art of War Quotes “He will win who knows when to fight and when not to fight” – We should only invest when there is clear benefit to do so, do not do something just for the sake of doing something. “If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear […]
In this thinking fast and slow book summary, I will explain to you the various human biases that we have and why it is important for us as investors to understand it. It all begins with a simple premise that we all have two systems in our brain, system 1 and system 2 […]
I chanced upon an edited transcripts from Guru Focus of an interview of Munger and Li Lu in one of China’s top finance magazines. Here are the 7 investing lessons I learned from Charlie Munger and Li Lu’s interview: 1. In investing, patience is very […]
As value investors, a lot of us talk about investing for the long run. But what does investing in the long run really mean? As a value investor, I have had companies that I made over 50% in less than 6 months because that company I owned got acquired. I have also had companies […]
Just finished rewatching all 95 episodes of The Romance of The Three Kingdoms – Although this is a classic Chinese historical war movie that is likely dramatized, there are a lot of lessons to be learned from it – for value investing purposes.  No matter how good we are or how much […]
Today I want to share with you my thought processes when I first initiated a position in Care.com (NYSE: CRCM) on 28 May 2019 – and less than 6 months later on 20 December 2019 – overall at an average cost of $10.07, I sold off all of it at $15.05. My valuation for care was higher than […]
Compound interest is very powerful. It is the interest you get on top of the previous principal + interest you already got. Here are 3 actions you can take to make the best use of compound interest: Invest early – the earlier we invest, the more powerful the compounding effect […]