Stock analysis/investing
High dividend yield, blue-chip stocks, is it safer? | Re-ThinkWealth.com
3 June 2021
Many investors love to invest based on high dividend yield alone. Are you one of them?
Some people think that dividend stocks are safer, but is it true?
In this article, I will be sharing some of the misconceptions we need to be wary of when investing in dividend stocks.
I will be answering some of the misconceptions like: are investing in “blue-chips”/dividend stocks safer or is investing in high dividend yield stocks good?
Are Dividend Stocks and So-called “Blue-Chips” Safer?
First, let me get it out of the way: stocks are not inherently safer or riskier because they are dividend stocks or “blue-chips”.
I personally view risk as a permanent loss of capital. What is your view of risks?
A dividend stock or “blue-chip” can be risky if the business is in a perpetual decline or if the management is destroying the value of the company through bad management (and as a result, the company has to cut dividends). And not only that, if the business does not perform well in the future, capital losses on top of dividend cuts are bound to come as well.
Essentially, dividend stocks or “blue-chips” can be very risky if we do not understand them well and as a result, we might be buying into a company whose future is going to become worst over time and their share price will reflect that. This is the definition of “value trap” – buying into a company whose shares have fallen and the share price falls further because the business did not improve for the foreseeable future.
Does High Dividend Yield Means It’s A Good Sign?
High dividend yield companies can be a potential sign of a “value trap”.
Remember, the dividend yield is calculated by taking the company’s latest dividends dividing it by the company’s current share price. Sometimes, a company’s share price may fall a lot and as a result, the dividend yield goes up.
But remember, the dividend yield is a lagging indicator. If the company’s business performance continues to do worse into the future, the company’s share price may fall further and the dividend may even be cut or eliminated entirely. A company is usually cheap for a reason.
Buying a company’s stock just because they have a high dividend yield without understanding the business and the future of the business can be a recipe for disaster.
So, What To Look Out For When Investing in Dividend Stocks?
Many investors like dividend-paying companies because of their ability to generate income on top of potential capital gains. But one thing to note is that both dividends and retained earnings technically should come from the same place, which is net income. Without sufficient net income, a company will need to cut or eliminate dividends, or else, it will not be sustainable.
Hence, when looking at dividend-paying companies, I believe that ultimately the key thing to note and look out for is whether the company’s business can sustain and grow over the long run or not. Because remember, sustainable dividends come from the business’s ability to generate sustainable returns on its equity over the long run.
To estimate how much more the company dividend can grow, it can be useful to use the sustainable growth rate formula to estimate it. Take the company’s ROE and multiplying it by the company’s retention rate (1 – dividend payout ratio). For example, if a company has an ROE of 15% and a dividend payout ratio of 0.5, that means that the company still has 15% x (1 – 0.5) = 7.5% more room to grow its dividends based on the sustainable growth rate formula.
When analyzing dividend stocks, look at it from the point of view of us becoming a business owner in that business. What do we want to see? We want to see whether the company has good management that has executed well in the past. We want to see their performance so far in terms of revenue growth, earnings, ROE, etc. We want to see if they are in any danger with regard to their leverage. We also want to see if the future of the company looks brighter than it is today or it is not. Among others.
In summary, when looking at dividend stocks, do not have the illusion that because they have a high dividend yield or it is a “blue-chip” company, it is safe.

Image source: Google
Safety comes from the business and managerial strength and us knowing what we invest in. Not simply whether they have a high dividend yield or it is a “blue-chip” company. Especially not simply because they have a high dividend yield. Just look at First Reit stock above, when it fell to around 90 cents, the dividend yield was getting higher – but as of now, it can be seen that they are all just an illusion because the business continues to perform poorly (a classic definition in my view, of a value trap at 90 cents).
Disclaimer:
The information provided is for educational and general information purposes only and is not intended to be personalized investment or financial advice. We make no promises as to the accuracy or usefulness of the information we present.
Important: Please read our full disclaimer.
Learned something?
Share this article with your friends in your WhatsApp or Telegram group now!

Chris Lee Susanto
Founder, investment blogger, and editor of this value investing x business-like stock investing blog Re-ThinkWealth.com.
Chris is a big proponent of business-like stock investing. He invests in companies where there is value to be found, be it a turnaround, depressed, value, or quality growth company (compounders). He either buys the stock outright or he profits through selling put or selling call options – or buying call options (buying and selling options are especially dangerous for those who do not know how to properly execute it).
Some of the places where Chris has been invited to speak or have added value as a mentor or writer includes Singapore Polytechnic, SMU Institute of Innovation and Entrepreneurship (IIE), Dollars and Sense, The New Savvy, Value Walk Blog, Investment Moats, NUS Tembusu College, NUS Investment Society, CGS-CIMB Singapore, Singapore Financial Conference by NTU IIC, The Financial Coconut Podcast, Money FM 89.3 and Internationally in Myanmar.
Being a full-time investor, Chris knows that he did not beat the S&P 500 return so far (as of the time of this writing) by listening to stock tips. So, when he teaches, he also doesn’t believe in giving stock tips as it is not sustainable for you in the long run.
As of now, Chris’s focus is on setting up a MAS Licensed Fund in the future with the goal to beat the market over the long run. Feel free to join his free investment telegram channel here to be the first to be updated on his new articles.
Don’t Leave First, Read Also:
Sustainability of Dividends
First, we must understand that business conditions are dynamic. Occasionally, different cycles will cause earnings to fluctuate up or down and it affects the business’ ability to pay out dividends. As investor, we must never have the expectations for dividends to remain the same forever […]
The Role of Synergies in M&A; Reliable to Warrant a Premium Over Market Value?
Today, I want to talk about the role of synergies in M&A. And is it reliable enough for companies to pay a premium over market value because of it?
I for one think that this is a very important topic to discuss for both investors and business people alike. Simply because people tend to be over optimistic of the future and […]
Warren Buffett Often Talks About Intrinsic Value: What is it?
Warren Buffett often talks about intrinsic value. But what exactly is an intrinsic value? Knowing what is intrinsic value is the FIRST step for any aspiring investors who want to be a practitioner of value investing. UNDERSTANDING what is intrinsic value is, of course, the second step for aspiring value investors. Because […]
My Thoughts on Qualcomm Q1 2018 Results
Yesterday’s was Qualcomm’s release of its quarter 1 2018 results. You can view its SEC filing here. It is for the quarterly period ended March 25, 2018. A short background, Qualcomm is simply the company behind most of the smartphones that we are using – in terms of the chips or you can call it, the “brain” […]
Good Result and Yet The Stock Fell 10+% – GameStop’s So Unloved
The stock hit fresh near 13 year low despite the company doing pretty well during the earnings call on 28 March 2018. It closes at 10.39% down. It is not an easy day for any GameStop holders (except the short sellers), from my end, I am thinking where I could have gone wrong – or is the market wrong. I am more than willing to […]
Here’s My Thoughts on GameStop’s Q417 Earnings Results (Released 28/3/2018)
Despite the increase in sales and the beat in earnings from analyst estimates, their profits are still down 11.4% year on year basis on the adjusted diluted EPS portion (from $3.77 to $3.34). However, $3.34 is near the top of the management guidance for FY2017 – and the focus on improving the trade awareness where […]
5 Reasons Why Having The Long-Term View is Vital in Stock Investing
Having a long-term view is important in stock investing. And the reason is not just because many of the world’s most successful and richest investors such as Warren Buffett and Seth Klarman say so. “If you aren’t willing to own a stock for ten years, don’t even think about owning it for ten minutes” – Warren Buffett […]
Is GameStop Doomed? I Visited Their Stores in NY to Find Out
As of the market close on 11 January 2018 at $19.96, I am at a 7.81% paper gain excluding of realized gains I received via dividends and options premium. And GameStop consists of 30.80% of my portfolio – second on the list – with the first being Qualcomm at 40.60% of my portfolio. Naturally, going down to GameStop stores in New […]
Last day of 2017 – A Review of My Investment Journey So Far
This year, the stock market rally would have given many investors with a good profit – the Dow (top 30 company in the united states stock market) up 25%, S&P 500 (top 500 company in the united states stock market) up 19% and Nasdaq are up 28% this year. And I think it is maybe time to be cautious. Or I should say, cautiously […]
Here’s My Opinion on Bitcoin
Bitcoin is a currency that was founded/discovered pretty recently in 2009 by a person (still unknown) using the alias Satoshi Nakamoto.The good thing about transacting using Bitcoin is that there will be no middleman required to do the transacting. There is also no fees tagged to transacting with Bitcoin and no requirements […]
What is moat in Warren Buffett’s terms & why it’s important
Moat is important because it protects a company from losing their market share easily which will erode its earnings power over time. This is important for us as investors because we would want the company we invest in to have its earnings grow over time – then the share price will follow – and not the other way round. So, we […]
GameStop Q3 17 Earnings — Glad Going Against The Crowd Was Right
25% of their stores have already been turned to GameStop plus format which is a 50–50 combination of games and collectibles. What is interesting here is that despite lesser space to put video games, they actually see an increase in video games sales. This got to do with the new types of customers that these […]











